Pictures captured by C.J. Kleingrothe have gained widespread acclaim for his or her beautiful illustration of colonial life in Sumatra’s plantations and society. But little is thought in regards to the lifetime of Kleingrothe and the narratives that impressed his work. This text goals to delve into his life and discover the tales behind his images, shedding gentle on their context and historic significance.
The start of the tobacco metropolis
Following the abolition of the cultuurstelsel coverage in 1870, the Dutch colonial authorities applied a liberal financial system within the Dutch East Indies that allowed non-public firms to take advantage of the colony’s assets. Searching for to determine the Sumatran Sultanate of Deli as a rival to neighbouring sultanates, the Sultan of Deli granted European planters a long-term, low-cost land concession to domesticate tobacco. With the virgin land obtainable, some pioneering planters took the chance to arrange tobacco plantations. The tobacco leaves produced in Deli shortly gained reputation and have been extremely valued as cigar wrappers in Europe and the USA. The period additionally marked the provision of business pictures.
How Indonesian studies’ “brand needy” lets Australian students down
There’s a robust case for supporting the research of Indonesian historical past and cultures in Australian universities.
In 1867–1870, Kristen Feilberg, a Danish photographer, documented his journeys to Deli and Sumatra in one of many earliest {photograph} albums of the area “Views from Deli and the Battak country“, which incorporates footage of early planters, plantations, and the Batak individuals, recognized for his or her fame as a cannibal tribe.
In the meantime, G.R. Lambert & Co. pictures studio was based in Singapore in 1875 and expanded all through Southeast Asia. In 1885, they opened a studio in Medan on the request of Deli plantation homeowners, with Heinrich Ernst turning into their first photographer there. In 1886, Hermann Stafhell, a Swedish photographer residing in Singapore, was invited to seize photos of the brand new railway tracks and station in Medan.
Stafhel and Kleingrothe
Carl Joseph Kleingrothe (1864–1942), also called Karl Josef or Charles Joseph, was born on September 24, 1864, in Krefeld, Prussia (northwest of Düsseldorf). Kleingrothe was 23 years outdated in 1888, when Lambert employed him as a photographer in Singapore and subsequently travelled to Medan.
Kleingrothe shortly discovered loads of work capturing photos of the constructing of town of Medan, its infrastructure, and the tobacco tradition within the space. In 1889, Kleingrothe and Stafhell established their very own pictures studio. Their plate digital camera and tripod captured images for tobacco firms, the Deli railway firm, official authorities occasions, and personal people.
![](https://www.newmandala.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Picture-1.png)
Stafhel and Kleingrothe’s studio had pure gentle that was coming into by a big window. The backdrop they used portrayed a tropical scene, full with palm timber and accompanied by props corresponding to a chair or desk and fabric draping. (Supply: Tropenmuseum, CC license).
As a consequence of their distinctive work, Stafhell and Kleingrothe grew to become famend in Medan and the area. Their albumen and gelatin silver print images showcased the colonial very best, emphasising the Deli pioneers’ spirit of conquering the wilderness and bringing modernity within the area. They arrived in Medan when Kesawan was nonetheless a village of picket outlets on the grime highway. Inside a number of years, Kesawan was reworked right into a central purchasing space.
Kleingrothe Atelier
In 1897, Stahfell determined to maneuver to Singapore, whereas Kleingrothe selected to stay in Medan and established his personal studio, the Kleingrothe Atelier. The studio occupied the higher flooring of three outlets in Kesawan with pure gentle from a vertical frosted glass wall, managed by sliding and folding curtains.
![](https://www.newmandala.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Picture-4-1024x477.jpg)
Kleingrothe Atelier (on the left). It’s on the second flooring of Kesawan, the constructing on the nook of Marktstraat (now Jl. A. Yani III) )(KITLV 181257)
Apart from pictures, Kleingrothe was an inventor. In 1904, Kleingrothe filed an invention of the design of roofing tiles in Singapore. Working in a harsh tropical surroundings, Kleingrothe provided the German picture paper trade a prize of a silver beer goblet value 300 marks to supply sturdy photographic matte papers.
Kleingrothe had a busy enterprise and fulfilled his responsibility as a toekang potret as outlined by Paul Faber: studio {photograph}, commissioned {photograph}, and images in assist of science.
In 1902, Johannes van den Model, a lawyer in Medan, launched an explosive booklet, De Millioenen uit Deli, or the Millions of Deli. It uncovered the appalling circumstances of the employees and systematic abuses by the Dutch planters to the plantation coolies. The general public within the Netherlands was deeply shocked by the account of the atrocious therapy of the plantation labourers.
To counter the adverse publicity, Kleingrothe launched an album of the Arendsburg tobacco firm. De Sumatra Put up, 10 November, 1903, reported:
For instance, the image “Chinese language Temple of Kloempang” which was a small temple however the entire look, due to the attractive composition, the attractive distribution of sunshine and shadow, is paying homage to a scene from “A Thousand and One Nights”. The “Park with Javanese homes” is a picture that we wish to have within the Groene Amsterdammer journal.
If the journal would reproduce this picture from the actual world as a counterpart to the beforehand unfold image, which was solely primarily based on lies, then many in Holland too, who now nonetheless regard Deli as a land of coldness and brutal violence, would be taught to see that they have been a bit too one-sidedly knowledgeable.
Kleingrothe was known as for visits, farewells, sports activities occasions, and events of vital company and officers. He made albums for big tobacco firms and was a dependable promoter. The Deli tobacco plantations have to have these constructive photos. On the Semarang Exhibition in 1914, the Deli tobacco affiliation made an effort to show “humanly talking full image of the tobacco tradition in Deli”.
![](https://www.newmandala.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Picture-5-1024x619.jpg)
Chinese language temple on the plantation in Kloempang close to Medan, Sumatra, 1903 (KITLV – 78467).
In these images, the hidden actuality of social hierarchy turns into discernible, shedding gentle on the contrasting positions occupied by European assistants and Asian labourers. One hanging instance is captured within the image depicting coolies sorting tobacco in a barn. The Chinese language coolies have been portrayed participating in strenuous labour, whereas the Europeans, positioned increased than the employees of their white apparel and holding a stick, emanated a way of authority.
![](https://www.newmandala.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Picture-6.png)
Coolies sorting tobacco in a barn of the Amsterdam Deli Firm in Medan, Sumatra (Kleingrothe ca 1900), KITLV 78329.
One other fascinating {photograph} showcases the home of a European assistant amidst the tobacco fields. The well-maintained tobacco crops and the diligent coolies amassing leaves have been superbly captured. An ox cart, pushed by an Indian employee, transporting the harvested leaves. Within the distance stands the European assistant in entrance of his home. Although smaller within the body, his apparel and manner exude a way of dominance.
Kleingrothe’s images captured the nuances of the interactions between Europeans and Asians. One explicit picture portrays two Europeans leisurely seated and having fun with beer, projecting a way of rest and dominance. In distinction, positioned within the background, a Chinese language servant fulfilled a subservient position.
![](https://www.newmandala.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Picture-8.png)
Two European males consuming Beck’s beer with De Sumatra and a Chinese language attendant on the again serving beer (Kleingrothe circa 1890). KITLV 155291.
Images of unique individuals
Kleingrothe’s pictures studio attracted a various clientele, together with Europeans, Chinese language, and Sultans. He captured images of individuals of various ethnicities in Medan, together with Malay, Javanese, Indians, and others. Nonetheless, Kleingrothe’s images typically depicted the native individuals in a stereotypical and exoticised method. Pictures of indigenous individuals grew to become standard postcards within the Dutch Indies, typically labelled as “Indische Typen” or Indonesian varieties. One notable instance is the {photograph} of a Batak man, taken in Kleingrothe’s studio, and described as an ex-cannibal. Kleingrothe used this fierce-looking man with a primitive look as an advertisement for his enterprise.
Kleingrothe additionally launched into a journey to Batak Karo villages, aiming to doc the lives of the indigenous. Via the assist of the plantation administrator and the village chief, he gained entry to 1 such village. Nonetheless, it took three days of persistent effort, using a ruse and the help of the chief, to coerce a few of the girls to take part within the {photograph}. The ladies, some minimally dressed, have been organized of their conventional home, to painting a picture of their cultural practices and lifestyle. His images ended up within the Museum of Ethnology in Berlin as a reference on Batak individuals for anthropologists and ethnographers.
These images venture a picture of the East Indies as an unique place with journey, highlighting the supposed “civilising mission” of the Dutch.
![](https://www.newmandala.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Picture-10.png)
Batak girls pounding rice in in Kampong Bandar Bringin, Sumatra (Kleingrothe ca. 1880), KITLV 101317.
C.J. Kleingrothe
Kleingrothe’s images have been used to create albums and postcards that documented the landscapes, structure, and folks of the area, turning into standard collector’s objects. The Austrian Geographical Society bought his images of the tropical forest to showcase unique tropical vegetation, corresponding to banana timber, which have been unfamiliar sights in Europe.
In 1903, Kleingrothe introduced his negatives to Munich to be reworked into photogravure prints, leading to ground-breaking albums such because the Deli Maatschappij and Sumatra’s Oostkust. Kleingrothe established himself as a creative photographer. He even gifted a replica of his album, certain within the pores and skin of a crocodile, to Queen Wilhelmina of the Netherlands, who expressed her appreciation. By the Nineteen Twenties, his albums have been extremely valued, and so they can now be present in museums worldwide.
Kleingrothe departed from Medan for Europe in 1915, presumably as a result of warfare and related anti-German sentiment. Whereas Kleingrothe captured many European working in Medan, I can not discover any image of him and little is thought about him. He lived and made a profession in Medan for 27 years (1888–1915) and retired to a calming life in Germany for the subsequent 27 years.
The Dangerous Nauheim metropolis archive recorded that, on the age of 51, Kleingrothe retired to Dangerous Nauheim, a resort city recognized for its salt springs. He led a contented life, married for the second time, owned a number of properties, ran a tobacco enterprise and operated a cinema. In 1928, Kleingrothe and his spouse departed from Dangerous Nauheim. As World Struggle II broke out, Kleingrothe and Maria have been registered as dwelling in Frankfurt am Essential. Kleingrothe handed away on February 25, 1942, in Frankfurt am Essential on account of influenza, coronary sclerosis, and hardening of the arteries.
Colonial life
Kleingrothe’s images depict the event of Medan from a small village right into a bustling colonial metropolis, the expansion of the tobacco trade, and the varied communities that lived there, offering a visible document of colonial life. These photos depict life, structure, landscapes, and apparel of the time. The rising availability of digital archives has made these images extra accessible to most people, and the Indonesian neighborhood is captivated by the aesthetic illustration of “tempo doeloe”, rekindling an curiosity in colonial life.
It’s important to acknowledge the selective nature of those images, a lot of which have been commissioned by plantation firms, and which served as advertising property for the businesses and the Dutch colonial authorities. Much like trendy advertising or social media platforms, these images have been fastidiously chosen to focus on sure features whereas downplaying or excluding others.
Whereas the images seize the wonder and growth of Medan and the tobacco tradition, their energy to form perceptions should be thought-about. These photos predominantly depict the constructive features or progress of colonisation. The transformation from a dense jungle to meticulously maintained plantations conveys a way of progress that seems to be doable solely by European intervention. By romanticising and idealising colonial life, these images inadvertently overlook the exploitation and oppression that occurred behind the scenes.
Equally, the ability dynamics between European overseers and their loyal staff in these photos emphasise racial superiority. These images promote the development of European expertise, downplaying the realities the colonised inhabitants confronted. The pictures depicted indigenous and non-European peoples as primitive stereotypes, reinforcing the concept they have been inferior and wanted to be “civilised”. These photos supported the concept the colonisers introduced order, civilisation, and progress to “primitive” societies.
Kleingrothe’s fascinating images, whereas offering a window into the previous, additionally function a reminder of the interaction between visible illustration, historic narratives, and the selective shaping of actuality.
Acknowledgement
The writer thanks the archivist of Dangerous Nauheim for serving to put collectively the file of C.J. Kleingrothe.
References
Stadarchiv Dangerous Nauheim 1915-1928.
Sterbebucheintrag des Karl Josef Kleingrothe (1942 / V / 372)
Frankfurter Adressbuch für 1941, 1. Teil, S. 370.