Chinese language authorities claimed that it could be a “violation of Asia-Pacific Financial Cooperation (APEC) guidelines” if the US bars Hong Kong Chief Government John Lee Ka-chiu from attending the APEC leaders summit in San Francisco in November.
The declare got here after media reviews that Washington plans to ban Lee from attending the assembly of 21 regional economies.
However the declare is deceptive. APEC pointers state visiting delegates are accountable for arranging their visas in the event that they require them. The Hong Kong chief is beneath sanctions that bar his entry into the U.S.
In a report revealed on July 27, The Washington Submit cited unnamed White Home officers as saying that the U.S. has determined to bar Lee from taking part within the APEC Financial Leaders’ Conferences (AELM) to be held in San Francisco from Nov. 15 to 17, 2023.
In response to the report, Chinese language International Ministry spokesperson Mao Ning said that refusing to ask Lee attributable to present U.S. sanctions in opposition to him was a mistake which “blatantly violates APEC guidelines and gravely contravenes the U.S. dedication because the host.”
Lee at the moment can not get hold of any U.S. immigrant or non-immigrant visas attributable to an earlier U.S. presidential order and subsequent sanctions imposed on him and 10 different Hong Kong officers implicated in a 2020 authorities crackdown in opposition to democracy protestors.
Hong Kong’s authorities pointed out in a separate assertion that because the host of AELM, the U.S. had a primary accountability to ask Hong Kong’s chief to the assembly.
Nevertheless the declare is deceptive. Under is what AFCL found.
Is the AELM host accountable for inviting the leaders of all APEC members?
Sure. Article 4 of APEC’s pointers for internet hosting conferences state that the host is meant to ship official invites no less than eight weeks prematurely of the assembly, after deciding upon the assembly’s location and time.
The rules additionally say: “APEC Leaders implicitly perceive that they’re invited to attend this assembly; the a call for participation from the host economic system’s chief is solely a formality.”
However Matthew Goodman, a former Nationwide Safety Council employees member who personally helped put together for APEC conferences, instructed AFCL that APEC’s pointers are neither associated to worldwide regulation nor legally binding.
![1.jpg 1.jpg](https://www.rfa.org/english/news/afcl/afcl-hk-apec-08132023231018.html/1-1.jpg/@@images/7bb53215-005a-4601-92d1-1a437b7c6ab4.jpeg)
Will invited representatives at all times be capable to attend AELM?
No. Part 12 of the rules states that each one delegates invited to attend APEC conferences are accountable for arranging any required journey paperwork themselves. The part doesn’t state that the host is required to subject them visas or waive coverage or legal guidelines that might prohibit an individual from coming into its borders.
“On condition that the home legal guidelines of host nations have to be revered, it isn’t proper to assert that the U.S. is violating APEC’s guidelines,” Goodman says.
What’s going to occur to Lee?
Unknown. A State Division spokesperson instructed AFCL that members of a overseas delegation should abide by U.S. legal guidelines and rules when taking part in APEC actions.
“The U.S. will work with Russia and Hong Kong to make sure they take part in AELM ‘in an acceptable means’,” mentioned the spokesperson with out elaborating additional.
Russian President Vladimir Putin is in an analogous state of affairs to Lee because of U.S. sanctions placed on him following the beginning of the Russo-Ukrainian struggle in 2022.
This implies Each Lee and Putin would want to safe a particular visa waiver from the U.S. in an effort to attend this 12 months’s AELM in San Francisco.
The APEC Secretariat has not responded to inquiries about Hong Kong and Russian leaders as of press time.
In the meantime, a spokesperson from Hong Kong’s Chief Government Workplace reiterated its earlier call on the U.S. to abide by APEC’s guidelines when inviting leaders to attend AELM.
“Hong Kong will attend the APEC assembly in accordance with APEC guidelines, pointers and practices,” the spokesperson instructed AFCL.
APEC pointers state that representatives can remotely attend AELM and different preparatory conferences main as much as the convention.
Is there a historical past of a number refusing to ask APEC member economies to AELM?
Sure – significantly within the case of APEC member Chinese language Taipei, as Taiwan is referred to by the 21-member grouping. China strongly objects to Taiwan’s participation because it regards the island as a part of China though Taiwan is self-governing.
When China hosted AELM in 2001, it did not invite any Taiwanese representatives, regardless of then-Taiwanese President Chen Shui-bian’s expressed want to attend in individual.
South Korea, the host of AELM in 2016, additionally refused to ask then-President of Taiwan’s Legislative Yuan Wang Jin-pyng to the assembly, requesting that Taiwan as an alternative ship an financial official reasonably than a political determine.
Australia, which hosted AELM in 2007, rejected Tsai Ing-wen, who had simply left her place as vice premier of Taiwan’s Government Yuan, for comparable causes.
![2.png (1).jpg 2.png (1).jpg](https://www.rfa.org/english/news/afcl/afcl-hk-apec-08132023231018.html/2-png-1.jpg/@@images/d76d6ff1-cd0b-498e-9187-bc0c59182bcd.jpeg)
Translated by Shen Ke. Edited by Taejun Kang and Mat Pennington.
Asia Reality Examine Lab (AFCL) is a brand new department of RFA established to counter disinformation in immediately’s advanced media surroundings. Our journalists publish each each day and particular reviews that intention to sharpen and deepen our readers’ understanding of public points.